Energy efficiency analysis of energy facilities using ranking methods

RELEVANCE. Increasing energy efficiency is one of the necessary conditions for modernizing the Russian economy. High energy intensity and energy efficiency analysis are due to the combined influence of a number of factors, both global and private. Thus, for electric grid organizations the problem of energy efficiency is a priority. Having at their disposal electrical grid facilities, including points of reception and transmission of electrical energy, electrical equipment and power transmission lines, electrical grid organizations incur huge losses caused by losses during the transmission of electrical energy, losses associated with the unaccounted share of electricity, as well as third-party factors. OBJECT. Conduct an analysis of the energy efficiency of an electric grid organization that has 10 branches. Form a hierarchy of energy efficiency indicators, determine the impact of each indicator on the integral indicator that reflects the energy efficiency of the facility. Conduct benchmarking, identify leaders and outsiders among power grid organizations. METHODS. To calculate the weight coefficients, the method of analysis of hierarchies in the classical and fuzzy formulations was used. Energy efficiency benchmarking was carried out by ranking power grid organizations according to the integral indicator of energy efficiency. RESULTS. A three-level hierarchy of energy efficiency indicators has been formed. A decision-making algorithm is presented when analyzing the energy efficiency of energy industry facilities. The weight coefficients of indicators and integral values of energy efficiency of organizations are calculated. The indicators that have the greatest impact on the overall efficiency of the facility were identified. A summary diagram of comparison of all branches has been formed, the most and least successful organizations have been identified. CONCLUSIONS. The analysis of energy efficiency, carried out using two methods of analysis of hierarchies, made it possible to identify the advantages and disadvantages of the classical representation of the method. Determination of leaders within the branch structure of the electric grid organization allows us to analyze the methods used to improve energy efficiency, as well as to introduce them in the future to less successful branches.

1. Davydov A.R., Kruze A.A., Krylova Yu.A. Statistical analysis of energy efficiency dynamics of the world economy // Moscow economic journal. – 2021. - №6. – 175-181 p.

2. Palamarchuk A.G. Analysis of the current state of energy saving in the Russian industry (part 2) // Scientific works of the FES of Russia. – 2020. – Volume 222. - №2. – 362-379 p.

3. Gnezdilov D.K. Analysis of measures to improve the energy efficiency of the use of energy resources for the trading network // Journal «Postulate».– 2021. - №2. – 7 p.

4. Ratmanova I.D. Approach to the assessment of energy consumption in the region based on the use of fuzzy logic // Status and prospects for the development of electrical and thermal technology (XXI Benardos Readings).– 2021. – 43-46 p.

5. Zaslavskii I.S., Kartashova E.E., Paskar' I.N. Methods for assessing the energy security of energy system facilities // Proceedings of the conference "Developing the Energy Agenda of the Future". – 2021. – St. Petersburg. – 299-304 p.

6. Lyubchenko V.Ya., Pavlyuchenko D.A. Rating assessment of energy efficiency indicators of the hierarchy analysis method // Journal "New in the Russian Electric Power Industry". – 2017. - №11. – 77-91 p.

7. Leccese F., Salvadori G., Rocca M., Belloni E. A method to assess lighting quality in educational rooms using analytic hierarchy process // Building and Environment. – 2020. – 27 p.

8. Saira Naseer, Huaming Song, Muhammad Shamrooz Aslam, Daud Abdul, Arsalan Tanveer, Assessment of green economic efficiency in China using analytical hierarchical process (AHP) // Soft computing in decision making and in modeling in economics. – 2021. 2489-2499 p.

9. Less V.M., Pavlyuchenko D.A., Lyubchenko V.Ya., Analysis of the energy efficiency of electric grid organizations using information and analytical systems // Proceedings of the scientific student conference «Days of Science NSTU-2021». – 2021. – 112-116 p.

10. Gaponov A.I. Synthesis of the method of analysis of hierarchies and the theory of fuzzy sets for solving problems of ranking // XVI All-Russian Scientific and Practical Conference "Theory and Practice of Economics and Entrepreneurship" with international participation – Simferopol – 2019. – 184-185 p.

11. Stojan Vasović, Aleksandar Dragašević, Slaviša Puzović, Sanja Puzović, Vladan Paunović, Comprehensive power transformers evaluation based on multi-criteria decision-making approach // Tehnički vjesnik. – 2021. - №5. – 1448-1455 p.

12. Fam Van Ty, Fuzzy method of analysis of hierarchies and application for the analysis of types and consequences of failures // Journal "Science and Business: Ways of Development".– 2021. - № 3 (117). – 49-52 p.

13. Tong Si, Chunbo Wang, Ruiqi Liu, Yusheng Guo, Shuang Yue, Yujie Ren, Multi-criteria comprehensive energy efficiency assessment based on fuzzy-AHP method: A case study of post-treatment technologies for coal-fired units // Energy. – 2020.

14. S.K. Saraswat, Abhijeet K. Digalwar, Evaluation of energy alternatives for sustainable development of energy sector in India: An integrated Shannon’s entropy fuzzy multicriteria decision approach // Renewable Energy. – 2021. - № 171. – 58-74 p.

15. Osman Taylan 1, Rami Alamoudi 1, Mohammad Kabli, Alawi AlJifri, Fares Ramzi and Enrique Herrera-Viedma, Assessment of energy systems using extended fuzzy AHP, fuzzy VIKOR, and TOPSIS approaches to manage non-cooperative opinions // Sustainability. – 2020. - № 12 (7). – 27 p.

16. Smirnova D.A., Gurko N.S. Enterprise energy efficiency. Analysis of the use of energy resources by regression methods // Journal "Chief Power Engineer"– 2021. - № 8. – 26-31 p.